I did not go looking for this connection. It found me, in the course of research aimed at something else entirely—establishing the documented facts of my ancestor Martin Turpin's life. What I found instead is that the family who took young Martin in, under Virginia's poor laws in 1797, was itself bound by marriage to one of the most famous survival stories of the American frontier—the story of Mary Draper Ingles (1732–1815). This article lays out the evidence for that connection.
Who was Martin Turpin, and why does this matter to his story?
Martin Turpin (b. 1783) is my fourth great-grandfather. At fourteen, with no parent able to support him in Montgomery County, Virginia, he was bound under the county's poor laws to a local landowner named David Love (1763–1827). He later made his way to Knox County and then Anderson County, Tennessee, where he married, farmed, and raised a family. David Love's wife, it turns out, connects that household to a story far larger than either man—which is what this article is about.
Who was Mary Draper Ingles?
On July 30, 1755, a band of Shawnee warriors raided the small frontier settlement of Draper's Meadow, near present-day Blacksburg, Virginia, killing several settlers and taking five captive—among them twenty-three-year-old Mary Draper Ingles, her two young sons, and her sister-in-law, Bettie Robertson Draper (the wife of Mary's brother, John Draper). The captives were marched roughly five hundred miles to a Shawnee town in present-day Ohio. That fall, Mary escaped and walked her way home through the wilderness—a journey of several hundred miles that took over a month and has since become one of the most famous survival stories of the colonial frontier, retold in books, film, and an outdoor drama still performed each summer in Radford, Virginia.
Mary Draper Ingles's story is not, on its own, part of my family's history. But Mary’s niece did play a role in the Turpin family saga. Her brother's daughter married into the very household my own ancestor depended on and lived with, first in Virginia and eventually in Tennessee.
Who was John Draper?
John Draper, born about 1730 in Virginia, was Mary Draper Ingles's brother.[^1] He married Elizabeth "Betty" Robertson in April 1754—the same Betty Robertson who was captured alongside Mary in the 1755 raid.^2 He lived at Drapers Meadow, in what was successively Fincastle and then Montgomery County, and he served as a captain in the Fincastle and Montgomery County militias—notably under the command of his own brother-in-law, Colonel William Ingles, Mary's husband.^3 Betty died in 1774; John lived on, remarried, and died in Wythe County, Virginia, in 1824.^4
This is a documented man, not a name recovered from tradition alone. His military service, his residence, and his family are all recorded.
Who was Mary Draper Love—and why does she matter to the Turpins?
John Draper’s daughter, Mary Draper, married David Love, probably in July of 1783 or 1784, in Montgomery County, Virginia.[^5] David Love was a landowner and mill operator on Neck Creek in the same county. It was David Love to whom my ancestor Martin Turpin was bound as a poor-law apprentice in 1797.[^6] The Loves later moved to Maury County, Tennessee, where both David and Mary are buried at Wilkes Cemetery in Culleoka.[^7]
None of that, by itself, connects Mary Draper Love to Mary Draper Ingles. A shared name alone is not conclusive evidence of a shared family. What follows is the evidence that closes that gap.
The evidence
Three independent sources establish that Mary Draper Love was the daughter of this specific John Draper—Mary Draper Ingles's brother.
First, the marriage bond itself. The bond executed for David Love's marriage states plainly that he "hath obtained Licence for his Marriage with Mary Draper daughter of John Draper."[^8] This is about as close to a primary source as this kind of question ever gets—a legal document executed at the time of the marriage, naming the bride's father directly.
Second, a published genealogical source. Marise Parrish Lightfoot's history of Maury County's Revolutionary War veterans records David Love's marriage "to Mary Draper, daughter of Capt. John Draper of Draper's Valley."[^9]
Third, and most decisively, a reviewed genealogical record. The Daughters of the American Revolution's Ancestor Database carries a record for John Draper (Ancestor #A033550) that matches every particular already established independently: born 1730, Virginia; residences at Drapers Meadow in Fincastle and Montgomery Counties; rank of Captain; service under "Col. William Ingles"; first wife Elizabeth Robertson, married April 1754.[^10] The lineage statement associated with this record names Mary Draper as the child of this John Draper and Elizabeth Robertson. I confirmed directly that this specific lineage entry carries no error flag; DAR does flag known problems elsewhere in a patriot's record when they exist, and this entry is clean.[^11]
A physical marker corroborates all of this on the ground. At Wilkes Cemetery in Culleoka, Tennessee, a plaque affixed to Mary Draper Love's own headstone identifies her as "daughter of Revolutionary soldier John Draper"—placed there in 2004 by the Samuel Hammond and Tennessee chapters of the DAR.[^12]
What this means
Let’s be precise about what has and has not been established. What is documented: Mary Draper, who married David Love, was the daughter of a specific, well-documented John Draper of Drapers Meadow—the same John Draper who was Mary Draper Ingles's brother. That makes Mary Draper Love the niece of Mary Draper Ingles, and it means that when my ancestor Martin Turpin was placed in David Love's household in 1797, he came under the roof of a woman who had grown up in the shadow of one of the most remarkable survival stories in Virginia's frontier history.
I do not know whether that association with such an extraordinary adventure meant anything to Martin himself. That's not something the record can tell us. But the family relationship itself is not just a hoped-for connection. It's documented.
Notes:
[^1]: National Society Daughters of the American Revolution, "Draper, John," Ancestor #A033550, DAR Genealogical Research System, Ancestor Database, accessed August 13, 2026.
[^2]: Ibid.
[^3]: Ibid.
[^4]: Ibid.
[^5]: David Love and Mary Draper, Marriage Bond, "Montgomery, Virginia, United States records," images, FamilySearch, image 222 of 854, Image Group Number 007740792.
[^6]: Virginia, County Court (Montgomery County), Order Book 10, 1797–1798, image 29 of 143, entry for May 2, 1797, "Montgomery, Virginia, United States Records," digital images, FamilySearch, accessed August 12, 2026.
[^7]: Find a Grave, memorial records for David Love (1763–1827) and Mary Draper Love (1768–1840), Wilkes Cemetery, Culleoka, Maury County, Tennessee.
[^8]: David Love and Mary Draper, Marriage Bond, cited above.
[^9]: Marise Parrish Lightfoot, Let the Drums Roll: Veterans and Patriots of the Revolutionary War Who Settled in Maury County, Tennessee (Maury County Historical Society, Bicentennial publication).
[^10]: National Society Daughters of the American Revolution, "Draper, John," Ancestor #A033550, cited above.
[^11]: Author's direct examination of the DAR Ancestor Database record, August 13, 2026.
[^12]: Author's personal visit to Wilkes Cemetery, Culleoka, Tennessee, August 2026; corroborated by a Maury County cemetery history documenting the 2004 grave-marking ceremony conducted jointly by the Samuel Hammond Chapter (Kosciusko, MS) and the Tennessee Chapter (Maury County, TN), National Society Daughters of the American Revolution.
